Ultrasonic Time of Flight Profiling in Paperboard Creasing
Ultrasonic time of flight profiling quantifies internal paperboard delamination during creasing by measuring out-of-plane elastic modulus drops.

Echo
Compressional stress pulses propagating through paperboard interact directly with the internal fiber arrangement. Paperboard is an orthotropic, multi-ply structure defined by three principal material directions: machine direction, cross-machine direction, and out-of-plane z-direction. Acoustic wave propagation along the z-direction reflects the internal elastic modulus of the fibrous matrix.
When an ultrasonic transducer emits a longitudinal compression wave normal to the board surface, transit velocity depends on the out-of-plane stiffness tensor component and bulk material density.
Fiber alignment governs sonic transmission. In undamaged paperboard, dense hydrogen bonding between refined cellulose fibers allows rapid acoustic wave passage. Typical z-direction sound velocity ranges from 700 to 1100 meters per second, depending on furnish composition, internal sizing, and calendering density.
Any mechanical disruption within the internal plies alters this transmission path, slowing down acoustic transit.
A 350 gsm Folding Boxboard conditioned at 23°C and 50% relative humidity yields a baseline z-direction ultrasonic velocity of 850 meters per second.
Measurement of transit duration across the caliper thickness provides a non-destructive method for evaluating structural integrity. The baseline time of flight equals board thickness divided by longitudinal sound velocity. In a 450-micrometer thick board with an uncreased z-direction velocity of 900 meters per second, the acoustic pulse traverses the material in exactly 500 nanoseconds.
Variations as small as five nanoseconds indicate internal density shifts or localized micro-fractures prior to visible surface deformation.

Acoustic Time of Flight Principles in Fiber Networks
Piezoceramic emitters direct ultrasonic compression waves through the caliper thickness of paperboard. High moisture slows wave velocity. High-frequency sound waves between 1 MHz and 5 MHz offer optimal spatial resolution for standard folding carton calipers ranging from 300 to 800 micrometers.
Lower frequencies lack the resolution to distinguish sub-surface delamination layers, whereas higher frequencies suffer severe attenuation from scattering within porous fiber voids.
Acoustic propagation through wood fiber networks is inherently dispersive. Sound waves attenuate rapidly as they encounter phase boundaries between solid cellulose walls and air-filled pores. In dense chemical pulp layers, such as those in solid bleached sulphate boards, acoustic impedance remains uniform across the caliper.
Mechanical pulp plies in folding boxboards contain coarse fiber bundles that scatter acoustic energy, creating distinct signal attenuation patterns. Time of flight calculation relies on detecting the precise arrival of the first wave peak above background noise levels.
Transducer pressure alters transit timing. Coupling mechanics represent a major variable during offline bench testing. Direct-contact transducers utilize solid delay lines or high-viscosity gels to eliminate air gaps at the board interface.
Dry-contact elastomer pads provide repeatable acoustic transmission without contaminating food-grade paperboard samples. Modern converting lines increasingly rely on non-contact air-coupled ultrasonic transducers operating at 1.5 MHz, which transmit acoustic pulses through focused air columns without physical sheet contact.

Out of Plane Modulus Sensitivity
Mechanical stiffness in the normal z-axis depends on inter-ply bond integrity. The elastic modulus component C33 measures the material resistance to normal strain along the thickness axis. In multi-ply cartonboard, C33 is substantially lower than in-plane elastic moduli C11 and C22 due to the planar orientation of wood fibers deposited during wet-end forming.
Creasing directly targets this out-of-plane weakness, forcing localized shear failure between internal plies.
Internal cracks attenuate high frequencies. As creasing rules indent paperboard into matrix channels, internal hydrogen bonds break, creating flat, microscopic air gaps between adjacent plies. These micro-delaminations dramatically reduce the effective out-of-plane modulus C33 within the crease zone.
Ultrasound cannot propagate efficiently across open air interfaces; acoustic waves must travel around internal delamination gaps or pass through remaining fiber bridges. This path elongation increases the measured time of flight by 15% to 80% relative to uncreased board areas.
Shorter transit times indicate dense fiber. The relationship between acoustic delay and internal stiffness reduction follows a inverse square square root law. A 50% reduction in C33 increases time of flight by approximately 41%, assuming constant sheet thickness.
In actual creasing operations, mechanical compression simultaneously reduces caliper within the score bead while creating internal voids. Accurate time of flight profiling requires dual-laser displacement sensors to measure local caliper changes simultaneously, isolating elastic modulus breakdown from geometric thickness reduction.
Setting penetration depth without accounting for longitudinal wave speed variations results in unseparated internal plies, leading directly to cracked linerboard on the folder-gluer line.

Shear
Indentation by steel rules forces local displacement inside paperboard plies. During die-cutting and creasing operations, a steel creasing rule pushes the paperboard into a female matrix groove of specified width and depth. This mechanical action imposes severe out-of-plane shear stress combined with transverse compression.
Paperboard converts this localized mechanical work into controlled internal delamination, forming a flexible internal hinge.
Creasing weakens out-of-plane bond strength. Without pre-conditioned internal delamination, bending board through 90 or 180 degrees generates high tensile stress in the outer printed liner. Excess tensile strain causes the top liner to fracture, exposing white raw fibers and ruining printed brand graphics.
Controlled shear failure along internal ply interfaces allows the board to collapse inward into the creasing bead, relieving surface tensile stress during folding.
Phase shifts reveal ply separation. Ultrasonic time of flight profiling tracks the spatial development of this delamination zone across the crease profile. By scanning an ultrasonic transceiver pair across the creasing bead in one-hundred-micrometer increments, technicians plot a two-dimensional map of acoustic delay.
Peaks in acoustic delay correspond to regions of maximum internal ply separation, allowing precise qualification of matrix setup parameters.

Matrix Penetration and Delamination Kinetics
Groove channels receive displaced board material during penetration. As the creasing rule reaches its maximum downward stroke, paperboard undergoes three distinct deformation phases: initial elastic compression, out-of-plane shear yielding, and ultimate plastic set. Matrix width and rule thickness dictate the angle of shear propagation, which typically extends at 45-degree angles from the rule edges toward the female channel corners.
- Mechanical alignment of creasing die and counter matrix block.
- Initial penetration of rule apex into top liner surface.
- Out-of-plane shear stress concentration along ply interfaces.
- Delamination crack initiation between central mechanical pulp plies.
- Lateral propagation of micro-cleavages across the crease width.
- Elastic recoil and residual stress relaxation upon tool retraction.
Rule width determines indentation force. If the female matrix channel is too narrow, the paperboard experiences excessive lateral compression without forming necessary shear delamination planes. This condition damages top liner fibers while leaving the internal core rigid.
Conversely, an excessively wide matrix channel produces incomplete shear breakdown, resulting in erratic fold lines and high folding resistance. Ultrasonic time of flight scans reveal narrow matrix conditions as sharp, narrow delay spikes, whereas excessively wide matrix channels present low, diffused acoustic delay profiles.
Dwell time stabilizes crease shape. Die-cutting presses running at 10,000 sheets per hour provide mechanical dwell times under five milliseconds at the bottom of the stroke. High-speed ultrasonic profiling proves that short dwell times reduce the total lateral extent of shear delamination compared to slow bench test presses.
Converting engineers adjust rule penetration depths upward by 15 to 25 micrometers on high-speed press setups to compensate for incomplete viscoelastic shear propagation during rapid impact.

Density Reduction along the Deformation Axis
Local volume expansion occurs as internal fibrous layers separate under stress. Although mechanical indentation reduces sheet thickness under the rule tip, the adjacent shoulders of the crease expand upward into the matrix void. Internal delamination creates microscopic void spaces that permanently alter local density.
Density drops inside the delaminated zone by 10% to 30%, further contributing to acoustic wave retardation.
| Paperboard Grade | Caliper (µm) | Grammage (g/m²) | Baseline Z-Velocity (m/s) | Creased Z-Velocity (m/s) | Baseline C33 (GPa) | Delaminated C33 (GPa) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Folding Boxboard (FBB) | 450 | 300 | 820 | 410 | 0.54 | 0.13 |
| Solid Bleached Board (SBS) | 380 | 320 | 1050 | 680 | 0.98 | 0.41 |
| Coated Recycled Board (CRB) | 480 | 350 | 760 | 340 | 0.46 | 0.09 |
| Kraft Backed Board (SUS) | 420 | 310 | 990 | 580 | 0.87 | 0.30 |
Flute crush invalidates thickness readings. In solid paperboard, density and elastic modulus changes occur simultaneously across the score width. Ultrasonic time of flight profiling isolates structural delamination from pure geometric deformation by correlating signal amplitude loss with transit delay.
Signal amplitude drops by up to 24 decibels inside fully delaminated zones due to multiple acoustic reflections at internal air-cellulose interfaces.
Sufficient internal delamination lowers bending resistance without rupturing the exterior linerboard surface during high-speed carton folding.
Quantitative analysis of acoustic waveforms allows separation of compression effects from shear failure. Compression without delamination increases sound velocity because density rises while fiber contacts tighten. Shear delamination decreases sound velocity because internal air gaps create impassable barriers for longitudinal waves.
When ultrasonic time of flight scans display increased transit times despite reduced local caliper, shear delamination has successfully occurred within the internal plies.
Deeper matrix channel geometry reduces folding resistance only until internal fiber shear reaches the outer liner boundary.

Array
Piezoelectric sensor pairs positioned across the line record spatial transits. Laboratory evaluation of creased paperboard historically relied on destructive bending moment tests or tedious cross-sectional optical microscopy. Ultrasonic time of flight array profiling replaces destructive testing by providing a continuous, non-contact map of internal damage across the entire length and width of a creased sample.
Linear transducer arrays scan creasing beads at high spatial resolution. By arranging miniature ultrasonic elements in a staggered linear pattern perpendicular to the crease line, automated test benches capture transit time profiles in seconds. Transducer pitch distances down to 200 micrometers allow precise identification of the delamination zone boundaries, peak damage centers, and unsymmetrical deformation caused by die mis-registration.

Transducer Alignment and Frequency Selection
High-frequency piezoceramic elements position opposite one another across the sheet caliper. Transmit and receive transducers align along a common acoustic axis perpendicular to the paperboard plane. Axis misalignments exceeding 0.5 millimeters introduce geometric path errors that obscure true time of flight shifts within narrow creasing beads.
- Transducer Center Frequency selection mandates a compromise between spatial resolution and acoustic signal attenuation through thick paperboard plies.
- Acoustic Focusing Lens geometries concentrate ultrasonic pulse energy into a spot size smaller than 300 micrometers on the board surface.
- Dry Coupling Elastomer Pads maintain constant mechanical contact pressure without leaving chemical residues on printed packaging substrates.
- Digital Signal Signal Digitizers capture acoustic waveforms at sampling rates of at least 100 megasamples per second to resolve nanosecond delay shifts.
Signal processing algorithms extract precise time of flight values from digitizer records. Cross-correlation matching between reference signals from uncreased board and signals from creased zones identifies arrival time differences down to 0.5 nanoseconds. Phase shift tracking provides additional sensitivity when signal attenuation weakens the primary compression wave front in severely delaminated boards.
Temperature controls maintain measurement stability. Acoustic wave velocity in ambient air changes by 0.6 meters per second per degree Celsius. Air-coupled ultrasonic profiling systems incorporate real-time temperature compensation sensors situated near the acoustic measurement gap.
Temperature changes alter air-path transits, introducing drift into uncompensated paperboard time of flight calculations.

Is Time of Flight Profiling Feasible Online?
Continuous board travel at high production speeds creates substantial signal jitter. Sheet fluttering on high-speed web presses or sheet-fed folder-gluers alters the transducer-to-board distance, obscuring transit changes within the board itself. Non-contact air-coupled arrays overcome web flutter by employing dual-frequency differential tracking, where a low-frequency reference channel measures air-gap distance while a high-frequency channel profiles internal board delamination.
High web speeds restrict dwell time per sensor element. At web running speeds of 300 meters per minute, a point on the paperboard moves 5 micrometers during a single acoustic pulse cycle at 100 kHz pulse repetition frequency. High-speed data acquisition architectures average multiple ultrasonic pulses across spatial bins, smoothing out micro-scale surface roughness while preserving macro-scale crease profile geometry.
Equipment vendors frequently attribute signal degradation during high-speed profiling to ambient humidity fluctuations rather than transducer misalignment.

Score
Deformed channels fold cleanly when internal delamination is correctly distributed. The mechanical quality of a crease determines its performance during high-speed carton erecting, filling, and sealing. Profiling time of flight across the crease bead delivers quantitative metrics that correlate directly with conventional physical test parameters, such as folding moment and crease stiffness ratio.
Air pockets arrest acoustic pulse energy. Peak time of flight delay across a crease profile indicates the maximum degree of internal ply separation. Integrating the area under the time of flight delay curve yields the Total Delamination Index (TDI), expressed in nanosecond-millimeters.
Higher TDI values indicate broader, more thorough internal delamination across the creasing zone.

Folding Moment Correlations with Ultrasonic Delay
Bending resistance decreases predictably when internal sound transits slow down. Standard test protocols measure the bending force required to fold creased paperboard to 90 degrees according to ISO 5628 guidelines. Standard crease quality assessments calculate the ratio of creased folding resistance to uncreased board bending stiffness.
Ultrasonic time of flight metrics demonstrate strong inverse linear correlation with 90-degree folding moments across all major paperboard grades.
| Rule Penetration Depth (mm) | Female Channel Width (mm) | Peak TOF Delay (ns) | Total Delamination Index (ns·mm) | 90° Folding Moment (mN·m) | Top Liner Crack Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.25 | 1.40 | 35 | 42 | 48.5 | None |
| 0.35 | 1.40 | 85 | 115 | 31.2 | None |
| 0.45 | 1.40 | 165 | 240 | 18.4 | None |
| 0.55 | 1.40 | 290 | 395 | 11.8 | Micro-cracking |
| 0.65 | 1.40 | 410 | 520 | 8.1 | Severe Liner Rupture |
Liner fracture destroys moisture barriers. Over-creasing occurs when excessive rule penetration depth crushes the board completely, tearing internal plies and fracturing the top coating layer. Over-creased board exhibits extremely high acoustic delay values exceeding 350 nanoseconds, accompanied by massive signal attenuation.
Time of flight profiling detects the transition from healthy internal delamination to destructive liner tearing, establishing clear upper limits for rule depth settings on converting lines.
Compliance with ISO 5628 standard testing parameters dictates that folding moment reductions exceeding sixty percent trigger automatic lot rejection.
Asymmetric delay profiles indicate die misalignment. When creasing rules enter female matrix channels off-center, internal delamination develops preferentially on one shoulder of the score bead. Ultrasonic profiling plots this asymmetry clearly: one side of the profile exhibits high acoustic delay while the opposite shoulder displays un-delaminated baseline values.
Cartons produced with asymmetric creases fold out of square, causing machine jams on high-speed cartoning equipment.

Substrate Variability across Board Classes
Different fiber combinations exhibit unique delamination behaviors under mechanical stress. Solid Bleached Board (SBS) consists of long, flexible bleached chemical fibers that resist internal shearing. Achieving adequate folding moment reduction in SBS boards requires high rule penetration depths, producing sharp, localized time of flight delay peaks.
Crease setup on SBS substrates requires tight control to prevent liner rupture while achieving target acoustic delay metrics.
- Folding Boxboard (FBB) features thick mechanical pulp inner plies that delaminate readily under low shear force, generating broad, smooth time of flight delay curves.
- Coated Recycled Board (CRB) contains short recycled fibers and starch binders that produce brittle internal bonds, resulting in erratic, discontinuous acoustic delay maps.
- Solid Unbleached Board (SUS) utilizes high-strength unbleached kraft fibers requiring elevated penetration forces to achieve target Total Delamination Index thresholds.
Recycled fiber board presents distinct quality control challenges. Variations in recycled pulp quality cause localized fluctuations in out-of-plane bond strength within a single roll. Ultrasonic time of flight profiling identifies weak spots in recycled boards where creasing rules cause full structural collapse rather than controlled ply delamination.
Quality assurance protocols specify acceptable time of flight variance limits across paperboard master rolls prior to high-volume converting runs.
Whether online non-contact acoustic profiling can fully replace destructive bending moment testing on high-speed converting lines remains an open industry question.

Audit
Quality assurance specifications define explicit operational limits for packaging runs. Implementing ultrasonic time of flight profiling within converting operations alters quality audit documentation and tool setup procedures. Converting plants transition from qualitative visual inspection of score beads to quantitative acoustic compliance dossiers, reducing make-ready times and scrap rates during initial press setup.
Tool wear alters crease geometry over extended production runs. Steel creasing rules experience gradual tip rounding, while counter matrix channels suffer edge erosion from abrasive paperboard coatings. As die tooling wears, actual penetration depth decreases and shear stress distribution widens, leading to reduced internal delamination.
Time of flight profiling monitors this mechanical decay continuously, prompting die maintenance before score cracking appears on finished packaging.

Threshold Specification for Crease Dossier Approval
Converting line parameter sheets state explicit physical boundaries. A complete crease verification dossier incorporates baseline acoustic parameters, calibrated delay thresholds, and real-time process control capability indexes. Quality managers establish baseline ultrasonic profiles for every approved combination of paperboard grade, caliper, and die tooling configuration.
| Quality Control Parameter | Conventional Visual Inspection | Ultrasonic TOF Profiling | Cost Variance per 100k Cartons ($) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Make-Ready Waste Sheets | 450 sheets | 120 sheets | -115.50 |
| Make-Ready Setup Time | 45 minutes | 15 minutes | -175.00 |
| Running Line Scrap Rate | 1.8% of run | 0.3% of run | -525.00 |
| Folder-Gluer Jam Downtime | 2.5 hours/shift | 0.4 hours/shift | -630.00 |
| Customer Reject Claims | 0.4% of shipments | 0.02% of shipments | -1,200.00 |
Consider a practical manufacturing scenario. Take a 40-tonne lot of 400-micrometer Folding Boxboard converted into pharmaceutical cartons at a press speed of 8,500 sheets per hour. Assume an uncreased baseline z-direction ultrasonic transit time of 480 nanoseconds.
The technical specification mandates a peak time of flight delay between 140 and 180 nanoseconds across all primary score lines, with a Total Delamination Index exceeding 180 nanosecond-millimeters.
- Uncreased Baseline Verification confirms sheet caliper of 402 micrometers and initial sound velocity of 837 meters per second.
- First-Off Press Sample Profiling measures peak time of flight delay of 95 nanoseconds, indicating insufficient rule penetration depth.
- Tool Adjustment Iteration increases creasing rule penetration depth by 35 micrometers, elevating peak time of flight delay to 162 nanoseconds.
- Concentric Matrix Verification confirms symmetrical delay distribution within 8% variance across left and right crease shoulders.
- Dossier Sign-Off registers certified compliance metrics into the line production database prior to approving full volume press execution.
Failure to meet acoustic delay specifications requires immediate operator intervention. When time of flight profiling indicates insufficient delamination, operators must adjust rule penetration depth or replace worn matrix tape rather than increasing folder-gluer belt tension. Correcting root mechanical causes at the die-cutter prevents downstream folding errors and eliminates customer packaging line stoppages.

Tool Wear Economics and Reject Limits
Counter matrix erosion alters indentation geometry over extended production shifts. Synthetic phenolic matrices wear faster than steel counter plates, expanding channel width by up to 100 micrometers after 200,000 impressions. Ultrasonic time of flight profiling tracks matrix deterioration in real time.
As matrix channels widen, acoustic delay curves flatten and broaden, signaling the precise moment matrix replacement becomes necessary.
Unmonitored matrix wear alters internal stress distributions and increases outer liner failure rates during automated packaging assembly.
Scrap reduction financial models prove the economic justification for acoustic profiling systems. Standard die-cutting operations lose 1.5% to 3.0% of total run volume to score cracking, misaligned folds, and gluer line jams. Ultrasonic time of flight monitoring reduces total converting scrap below 0.5% by maintaining strict control over internal delamination metrics.
On a high-volume packaging line running fifty million cartons annually, scrap reduction savings exceed ninety thousand dollars per year.
Standard delivery agreements enforcing ISO 187 conditioning compliance shift financial liability for humidity-induced score cracking back to the board converting facility.




