Dynamic Mechanical Analysis Caliper Retention Testing for Multi-Layer Boxboards

Dynamic Mechanical Analysis quantifies z-axis caliper loss under dynamic converting loads to prevent carton collapse and protect structural bending stiffness.

26.09.26 11 min

Ply

Bending resistance in multi-layer paperboard depends on keeping dense surface fibers separated from the neutral axis. In folding boxboard, that balance comes down to furnish distribution: bleached chemical pulp forms smooth outer skins, while the core uses high-yield thermo-mechanical pulp, chemithermomechanical pulp, or secondary recycled fiber. The arrangement builds caliper without loading on basis weight.

Because bending stiffness scales with outer-skin elastic modulus multiplied by the third power of total thickness, even slight thinning in the center plies degrades panel rigidity.

How well a board holds up during converting and storage largely reflects its z-direction stability. Chemical pulp liners provide tensile strength and spring back well after loading, whereas mechanical pulp cores depend on the unrefined bulk and open lumen structure of stiff fibers to maintain sheet volume. Under dynamic surface compression, internal voids collapse while bonds between fibers take heavy shear loads.

High-yield pulps hold their bulk in resting conditions, but the cell walls flatten out once dynamic stresses exceed yield limits.

A ten percent reduction in middle layer thickness decreases total package stiffness by nearly twenty-seven percent.

Coated recycled boards introduce other vulnerabilities under mechanical load. Repeated repulping shortens cellulose fibers, hornifies cell walls, and flattens lumen cavities. To hit target thickness, mills add mineral fillers and starch binders to recycled cores.

Under dynamic compression, however, unbonded filler shifts between shortened fibers, leaving recycled plies with far less z-axis elastic recovery than virgin mechanical furnish.

  • Crease cracking occurs when a score line loses internal thickness, forcing outer chemical liners to stretch past their elongation limit.
  • Bulge deformation appears on filled cartons when sidewall core layers give way under the hydrostatic pressure of contents during transport.
  • Corner collapse develops when vertical edges take permanent thickness loss under dynamic top-load stacking.
  • Delamination splitting occurs when internal shear exceeds the interlaminar bond strength of compressed core plies.

Assessing multi-layer board means looking at the viscoelastic response of each furnish layer rather than treating the structure as a single sheet. Bench micrometers apply a static foot for a fixed dwell, hiding the plastic strain that develops inside mechanical core plies under real conditions. Overlooking that dynamic loss usually leads packaging engineers to specify higher basis weights than necessary, simply to cover up failures on high-speed converting lines.

A human finger points at the cross section of a multi layer composite material resting upon a metal industrial shelf.

Amplitude

Tracking caliper retention under sinusoidal compression involves sweeping oscillatory loads across target frequencies. Dynamic Mechanical Analysis applies cyclic through-thickness stress or strain, separating the elastic energy stored by the fiber matrix from the viscous dissipation caused by polymer movement. Total compressive resistance is captured by the complex modulus: its real component, the storage modulus, reflects elastic thickness recovery, while the imaginary loss modulus tracks unrecoverable viscous deformation.

The ratio of the two gives tan delta, measuring internal damping.

Because fibre orientation influences sheet behavior, testing within the linear viscoelastic region requires finding the strain limit where storage modulus remains independent of force amplitude. Standard protocols run sinusoidal compression between zero point one and one hundred Hertz under ISO 187 climate conditioning. Small strain amplitudes keep inter-fiber bonds intact to isolate baseline properties, whereas broader strain sweeps crush cell walls, marking the onset of permanent plastic deformation.

At eighty-five percent relative humidity and thirty degrees Celsius, mechanical pulp core plies lose forty-two percent of their dry compressive storage modulus.

Moisture changes storage modulus substantially. Water disrupts hydrogen bonding within the amorphous cellulose and hemicellulose networks of the fiber walls, depressing glass transition temperatures into typical ambient ranges. During dynamic cycling, higher humidity drives sharp peaks in tan delta, and this loss of core elasticity accelerates caliper drop across the entire sheet.

Quantifying z-axis dynamic properties across humidity shifts follows a defined sequence:

  1. Mount a thirty-millimeter diameter circular test specimen between parallel titanium compression platens inside the environmentally controlled DMA chamber.
  2. Apply a static pre-load force of zero point five Newtons to establish uniform contact across the sheet surface without exceeding the elastic limit.
  3. Set the environmental control system to establish baseline conditions at twenty-three degrees Celsius and fifty percent relative humidity for two hours.
  4. Execute an amplitude sweep from zero point zero one to fifty micrometers at a fixed frequency of one Hertz to establish the linear viscoelastic boundary.
  5. Apply an oscillatory force within the linear range while stepping the environmental chamber humidity from fifty percent to eighty-five percent relative humidity at one percent per minute.
  6. Record continuous measurements of dynamic displacement, storage modulus, loss modulus, and tan delta throughout the humidity ramp.
  7. Calculate the permanent displacement offset after returning the specimen to baseline humidity conditions and unloading the compressive force.

Dynamic testing shows wide variation in caliper retention across packaging grades, as summarized below.

Dynamic Mechanical Analysis Caliper Retention and Modulus Properties of Commercial Boxboards (Conditioned ISO 187 vs High Moisture Ramp)
Grade Family Gsm (g/m²) Caliper (µm) Baseline E’z (MPa) Ramped E’z (MPa) Tan Delta Peak Retention (%)
Folding Boxboard (GC1) 280 410 14.2 8.8 0.12 88.5
Folding Boxboard (GC2) 280 455 11.8 6.2 0.18 81.2
Solid Bleached Board (GZ) 300 380 18.5 12.4 0.08 92.1
Coated Recycled Board (GD2) 320 420 9.4 4.1 0.26 72.4
Solid Unbleached Board (SUB) 310 430 16.1 10.9 0.10 89.6
Baseline test conducted at 23°C / 50% RH, 1 Hz frequency, 5 µm amplitude. Ramped test measured at 30°C / 85% RH. Retention expressed as percentage of original ISO 534 thickness retained following dynamic load cycle.

Mill technical sales teams often attribute post-converting bulk loss to minor variations in ambient mill humidity during winding. Swatch-book caliper tolerances apply to unprinted, uncalendered raw board straight off the reel, whereas performance drops emerge once sheets pass through converting equipment.

Nip

High-speed converting rollers subject paperboard webs to compression pulses that alter fiber density in milliseconds. Sheet-fed offset presses, flexographic coaters, and gravure units rely on high nip pressure to transfer ink and coating formulations. An impression cylinder typically generates local z-direction pressures between one point five and three point five Megapascals, with dwell times ranging from two to fifteen milliseconds depending on line speed.

That pulse exceeds the static yield stress of mechanical core plies, compressing the furnish abruptly.

Concentric rings of colored pleated paper sheets surround a central metal clamping chuck mounted inside a dark testing booth.

How Does Dynamic Nip Dwell Time Alter Caliper Recovery?

Nip contact drives air out of core pores and forces fiber segments into tight alignment. Leaving the nip, chemical surface plies recover almost immediately, while mechanical cores rebound slowly through time-dependent viscoelastic relaxation. Running lines faster cuts dwell time and limits viscous flow, but the accompanying pressure spikes can permanently collapse hollow CTMP fiber lumens.

Dynamic Compression Recovery and Permanent Caliper Loss at Variable Line Speeds and Dynamic Nip Pressures
Line Speed (m/min) Peak Pressure (MPa) Dwell Time (ms) Immediate Loss (%) Recovered (24h) (%) Permanent Loss (%)
150 1.5 12.0 8.5 6.2 2.3
300 1.5 6.0 6.8 5.3 1.5
150 3.0 12.0 16.2 10.1 6.1
300 3.0 6.0 13.4 9.0 4.4
450 3.5 4.0 14.8 9.2 5.6

Converting setups with inline calendering or multi-station print decks compound thickness loss across successive stations. Sending board through four consecutive print nips accumulates plastic deformation, stripping away sheet caliper well before the web reaches scoring rules and die cutters.

Converting setups typically rely on several operational checks:

  • Threshold stress evaluation establishes the dynamic storage modulus limit on laboratory DMA instruments prior to setting press impression pressures.
  • Line speed adjustments balance dynamic compression dwell time against throughput targets to minimize core ply crushing.
  • Anvil clearance setting optimizes die-cutting cylinder impression gaps to prevent localized board destruction adjacent to score lines.
  • Moisture window verification ensures press room atmospheric control remains strictly within forty-five to fifty-five percent relative humidity.

Packaging laboratories continue to investigate whether high-speed printing nips trigger micro-fractures in starch-bound mechanical plies that progressively undermine long-term box compression strength.

A mechanical gear assembly shreds a brown paper substrate directly into a laboratory desiccator for chemical analysis of moisture content and material composition.

Creep

Warehouse pallets stacked four high subject cartons to continuous static loads aggravated by transit vibration. Cartons held in unconditioned fulfillment centers sit under compressive stress for weeks or months. That static load, paired with transport vibrations between five and fifty Hertz, drives compressive creep through the core plies.

Over time, fibers shift and buckle microscopically, causing caliper to decay continuously.

Shifting humidity accelerates creep through mechano-sorptive deformation. As moisture in the sheet swings between ambient extremes, internal stresses redistribute under load. Along with transport vibration that loosens fibre bonds, each absorption cycle softens cell walls, enabling static weight to crush remaining void space.

When humidity falls again, the consolidated structure sets in place, locking in the lost caliper.

Compliance with ISO 187 conditioning guarantees static test accuracy but fails to predict dynamic thickness decay in unconditioned freight containers.

Caliper loss directly undermines Box Compression Test ratings. Stacking performance relies on panel bending stiffness alongside corner column strength. Because bending stiffness drops at a cubic rate when thickness decreases, creep pushes the load almost entirely onto carton corners until the vertical edges buckle, resulting in collapsed pallets during transit.

  • Z-direction modulus profile provides continuous dynamic storage and loss modulus values across operating temperature and humidity spectrums.
  • Dynamic humidity decay curve documents total thickness retention percentage during forced moisture cycling under constant compressive stress.
  • Permanent thickness offset report details post-load dimensional recovery measured exactly twenty-four hours after releasing static pre-load.
  • Batch statistical variance distribution declares upper and lower control limits for basis weight and bulk thickness across the manufacturing run.

Quality assurance contracts incorporate technical supply terms to enforce board structural integrity: “The substrate supplier warrants a minimum z-axis dynamic storage modulus of ten Megapascals measured under zero point five percent dynamic strain at eighty-five percent relative humidity, ensuring total sheet thickness retention stays within four percent of certified ISO 534 baseline values over a sixty-day static load duration.”

Precision measuring calipers clamp multiple fiber substrate strips outdoors among snow covered rocks under an overcast grey sky.

Tariff

Pricing board by mill tonnage runs counter to converted yield economics. Paper mills sell by weight, quoting per metric tonne, whereas converters sell cartons by volume, needing surface area at exact caliper thresholds to run smoothly on packaging machinery. Choosing low-density, high-bulk folding boxboard trims the tonnage required for a fixed carton count.

But if a lighter high-bulk sheet thins out under converting pressures, finished cartons fail specification, pushing converters back toward heavier grades.

Replacing virgin folding boxboard with recycled material looks economical on a per-tonne quote. Recycled grades carry lower base prices than virgin fiber, but DMA shows they have lower compressive storage modulus and higher dynamic loss. Matching the stiffness of a three-hundred-micrometer virgin GC2 board requires specifying a substantially heavier recycled GD2 grade, which wipes out the per-tonne discount through lost sheet yield per ton.

Commercial Yield, Bending Stiffness, and Landed Cost Comparison for Virgin vs Recycled Boxboard Grades
Grade Grammage (g/m²) Initial Caliper (µm) Retained Caliper (µm) Retained Stiffness (mNm) Yield (m²/tonne) Cost per 1,000 Sheets ($)
Virgin FBB (GC1) 250 380 355 18.2 4,000 437.50
Virgin FBB (GC2) 230 380 335 15.4 4,347 391.03
Recycled Board (GD2) 310 380 295 10.8 3,225 480.62
Recycled Board (GT2) 290 380 310 12.5 3,448 464.03
Calculations based on $1,750/tonne for GC1, $1,700/tonne for GC2, $1,550/tonne for GD2, and $1,600/tonne for GT2. Sheet dimensions: 700 mm x 1000 mm. Retained properties measured after press compression simulation.

Take a production run of one million cartons requiring a post-converting caliper of at least three hundred and fifty micrometers on seven hundred by one thousand millimeter sheets. Virgin Folding Boxboard GC2 at two hundred and fifty grams per square meter starts at four hundred micrometers. After nip compression and folding-gluing, the board registers twelve percent caliper loss, leaving three hundred and fifty-two micrometers to clear specification.

One million sheets require one hundred and seventy-five metric tonnes of board. At one thousand seven hundred dollars per tonne, material spend reaches two hundred and ninety-seven thousand five hundred dollars.

Switching to a recycled GT2 board offers an initial caliper of four hundred micrometers at three hundred and twenty grams per square meter. Because of lower z-axis storage modulus, the recycled sheet loses twenty-two percent of its thickness during conversion, finishing at three hundred and twelve micrometers ~ well below threshold. Reaching three hundred and fifty micrometers after processing requires stepping up to a three hundred and seventy gram per square meter GT2 board.

Required tonnage rises to two hundred and fifty-nine metric tonnes. Even at one thousand six hundred dollars per tonne, total substrate spend reaches four hundred and fourteen thousand four hundred dollars. The cheaper recycled stock increases material expense by thirty-nine percent and adds eighty-four tonnes of freight weight.

Specifying extra basis weight to recover lost thickness inflates freight charges and increases extended producer responsibility fees without restoring core elasticity.

Dynamic mechanical analysis isolates viscoelastic limits across multi-layer plies, turning converting risks into measurable parameters. Auditing storage modulus under dynamic loading protects sheet yields and holds mills to verifiable physical standards.

Nomenclature

Bending Stiffness

Flexural Resistance ~ Physical resistance offered by a paperboard sheet or corrugated board panel against external bending moments defines fundamental structural rigidity in folding carton converting.

Relative Humidity

Atmospheric State ~ Ratio of the amount of water vapour present in the air to the maximum amount the air could hold at that temperature dictates the moisture exchange with porous materials.

Dynamic Nip Compression

Roll Geometry ~ Linear deformation across opposing cylinders governs how moisture escapes from a wet web during press section transit.

Caliper Loss

Thickness Reduction ~ Material compression of paperboard under pressure represents a permanent decrease in thickness that affects the structural integrity of the substrate.

Linear Viscoelastic Region

Mechanical Boundaries ~ Material behavior under low levels of mechanical stress determines the range wherein paperboard deforms reversibly without permanent structural damage.

Basis Weight

Mass Specification ~ Total weight of a fixed area of paper or board measured under controlled environmental conditions.

Tan Delta

Damping Factor ~ The ratio of the loss modulus to the storage modulus in a viscoelastic material defines the damping behavior and energy absorption of a polymer coating or packaging adhesive.

Solid Bleached Board

Substrate Composition ~ Premium virgin fibre packaging stock derives from chemical pulp refined through multi-ply cylinder machines to secure high stiffness and pure white surfaces without recycled contamination.

Chemithermomechanical Pulp

Production Mechanism ~ Chemical impregnation followed by high-temperature mechanical refining describes the fundamental nature of this fiber class.

Landed Tonnage Cost

Cumulative Valuation ~ Total expenditure for imported paper products includes every cost associated with moving the material from the mill to the final warehouse.

Storage Modulus

Elastic Behavior ~ The measure of a material's stored energy during deformation defines the elastic behavior of a polymer coating or hot-melt adhesive used in paper packaging.

Viscoelastic Creep

Stress Relaxation ~ Dimensional instability under sustained loading occurs when molecular chains in cellulose substrates slowly rearrange over extended exposure to static tension.

What the firm knows, published

Expertise is a utility, not a secret. sentiention™ publishes its working knowledge as open reference: intelligence layer covering the materials it sources, the markets it enters, and the reference that serves both.